Min Price
Max Price

Welcome to Benn Realty!

Benn Realty celebrates 50 years strong, serving our clients needs as a full service agency since 1968. With two offices to serve you better, we are ideally positioned and ready to serve Buyers and Sellers in Northern Oneida county, and Southern Lewis and Herkimer Counties! At Benn Realty, we are proud to feature a variety of properties in any environmental setting! From the deep natural woods for the more adventuresome nature lover,  to seasonal and year round residential homes and camps, most on or near one of our many recreational lakes for the family who enjoys boating and water sports. Our newest office in Old Forge gives you access to experienced agents that live and work in the area, and that are passionate about their community! 

Crystal clear Mountain streams with cascading rapids and deep, still water pools for fishing and swimming. 

Pristine, Quiet, Adirondack lakes for those who seek peaceful solitude and a respite from their busy lifestyles. 

Our selection of properties varies greatly, depending on the season, but we strive to offer a wide variety for your consideration during prime spring and early summer season, as well as the hunting and snowmobiling season.  We offer properties in the tri-county areas of Northern Oneida, Herkimer and Lewis counties. Types of properties we offer, but are not limited to, are:

Vacant Lots
Snug Little Cabins
Year Round Residences
Spacious Waterfront Estates

Let us find the key to your dreams!

Meet The Team

Natalie Roth

 Lic. R.E. Broker

Cell: 315-240-3443

Edward "Ed" Benn

Lic. R.E. Associate Broker

Cell: 315-723-1814

Beth Frank-Roberts

Lic. R.E. Associate Broker

Cell: 315-796-1934

Heidi Westcott

Lic. R.E. Salesperson

Cell: 315-796-9034

Audrey Strutynski

Lic. R.E. Salesperson

Cell: 315-559-8957

Elaine Nelson

Lic. R.E. Salesperson

Cell: 315-271-9223

MaryAnn Nelson

Lic. R.E. Assoc. Broker

Cell: 315-369-8603

James Foley

Lic. R.E. Salesperson

Cell: 315-794-9460

David Bradt

Lic. R.E. Salesperson

Cell: 917-698-3473

Keith Brown

Lic. R.E. Salesperson

Cell: 315-520-5699

Cheryl Gager

Lic. R.E. Salesperson-REO Specialist

Cell:  607-244-2754


2946 State Rt 28
PO Box 188
Old Forge, NY 13420-0188
Office: 315-369-ADKS (2357)
Fax: 315-369-2355

11098 Lake Julia Rd
Remsen, NY 13438
Phone: 315-831-5061

Testimonials Page

I cannot put into words how thankful my husband and I were to have worked with Natalie on helping us find (and close on!) our very first home here in Rome, NY. From the very beginning, she was just on top of EVERYTHING. We had an initial sit down to talk about neighborhoods, our budget, etc. and  she worked to put together a plan. She sourced homes for us to check out and it wasn't uncommon to me to receive emails from her in the middle of the night with updates or just checking in. She was also very much in tune with what our priorities were when looking for our home. We are expecting our first child in August and we really wanted to be settled into our new home as fast as possible. We located and closed on our dream home in about 35 days! She came to the table with vendor relationships and recommendations which proved to be invaluable. People who would go out of their way to pull ME aside and tell me how much they love working with Natalie. How often can you say that about your real estate agent? On top of everything else, Natalie guided us through the entire process with a smile. Besides her sharp professionalism and attention to detail, she brought personality, humor and levity to every single day, something that two nervous first-time buyers appreciated so much. I guess it goes without saying, but Natalie will be our agent of choice for all of our future real estate endeavors, as well as a new life long friend. Cannot. Recommend. Her. Enough.  Dan and Lindsey Hale-5/14/2019
We highly recommend Heidi Westcott as a realtor. She went the extra mile, placing signs and posters in many different places. Heidi helped us out doing many extras since we didn't live near by. She is professional, dedicated, honest and pleasant which helped not only us but prospective buyers.   We felt like selling our house was her top priority. She sold our house in four months and it was a very positive experience. Elble
View All